Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

In order to help minimize spread of the coronavirus and protect our campus community, Cowles Library is adjusting our services, hours, and building access. Read more...

Cowles Library

 

FYS Toolkit: Scholarly vs. Popular

A collection of tools to use for FYS instruction.

Scholarly vs. Popular vs. Trade Periodicals

Scholarly Popular Trade
Publication itself
  • Title clearly identifies the subject
  • Often black & white
  • Matte paper
  • Few (or no) advertisements or photos
  • Scholarly, professional org., or university press
  • Published less frequently (monthly, quarterly)
  • Content is peer reviewed
  • Short, attention-grabbing title
  • Color
  • Glossy
  • Lots of advertisements and images
  • Commercial publisher
  • Published frequently (weekly, bi-weekly)
  • Content is not peer reviewed
  • Title usually identifies the trade
  • Color
  • Glossy
  • Some ads, usually trade-related
  • Published less frequently
  • Content is not peer reviewed
Articles (and Books/Chapters)
  Audience Scholars and students General audience Members of a specific business, industry, or organization
  Authors
  • Scholars, researchers, or experts in the field of study.
  • Affiliation and/or credentials provided.
  • Usually aren't experts in the field of study.
  • Employed and/or paid by the publisher.
  • Credentials usually not listed.
  • Staff or contributing authors.
  • Credentials usually not listed.
 Documentation
  • Sources cited in bibliography and/or footnotes.
  • Can use references to extend your research.
  • Sources not cited (or cited informally).
  • Varies, but usually sources are not cited.
  Purpose
Report results of original research or experimentation.
Provide general information or entertainment.
Provide information about industry trends, news, products, or techniques.
  Scope
  • Typically lengthy (articles: >5 pages)
  • Follows a structure (abstract, intro, literature review,
  • methods, results, discussion)
  • Usually has a narrow focus about a specific aspect of a topic.
  • Short (articles: <5 pages)
  • May present a broad overview of a topic, but little detail.
  • Short
  • Discusses a specific topic within a trade.